Abstract
Lyme disease has been a topic of debate practically since its discovery in the 1970’s. The hot topic is whether or not long-term antibiotics should be used for Lyme disease patients with persistent symptoms. The source of such a long-running debate stems from the difference in opinions over the cause of long-term, persistent symptoms after treatment in some patients. Toward its end, Medicine has finally begun to embrace the existence of Chronic Lyme Disease, but changes still need to be made in the future.
Author Contributions
Academic Editor: ANGELA Pia Cazzolla, professor for the Master degree of Dentistry and for the in Pediat Vocational Masters Degree ric Dentistry and Dental Traumatology at University of Foggia, Italy.
Checked for plagiarism: Yes
Review by: Single-blind
Copyright © 2019 Kenisha J Evans, et al.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Citation:
Introduction
Lyme disease, also known as Lyme Borreliosis, is caused by Borrelia burgodorerisensulato, a spirochete that is transmitted by ticks of the Ixodes ricinuscomplex 1, 2. This disease was first discovered in Lyme, Connecticut, a small town in eastern Connecticut. Beginning in 1972, a cluster of children had developed what appeared to be juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. Investigators discovered most of these children lived or played in wooded areas with the peak incidence of new cases coincide with tick season, summer and early fall. Additionally, many of the children reported having an unique characteristic annular rash prior to the onset of arthritic symptoms and some even recalled having a tick bite at the same location that the rash had developed3. Although the exact cause still had not been identified, the investigators termed these constellation of symptoms, Lyme disease 3.
It was not until 1977, Allen Steere, a rheumatologist at Yale, affirmed Lyme disease as its own entity 4. In a prospective study Dr. Steere and a team of researchers evaluated 48 patients with erythema chronicum migran as its initial marker for the subsequent development of Lyme arthritis. They discovered serum cryoprecipitates associated with the disease clinical activity involving skin and joints 5. The term erythema chronicum migrans had originally been used by European researchers in the early 1900’s, in their evaluation of a similar pattern annular skin rash. Nevertheless, in 1981, it was Willy Burgdorfer and his colleague, Alan Barbour, who were studying spirochetes (spiral- shaped bacteria) from deer ticks, who discovered the same spirochete that caused both erythema migrans and Lyme disease.
Since that time, to present date, much research has been done and a lot has been discovered about Lyme disease. However, there is a large part that is still unknown, which has caused confusion and controversy regarding the diagnosis and treatment of this disease.
Epidemiology
According to Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), Lyme disease is the most commonly reported vector-borne illness in the United States (U. S.). In 2015, the Center for Disease Control (CDC) reported the majority of Lyme cases were concentrated in the upper Midwestern and Northeastern, however the disease has migrated to other regions of the U. S. In some southern areas of the U. S., a number of cases have been documented of erythema migrans- like lesions 6. However there is a relatively lower incidence
observed in Northwest regions due to difference in feeding habits of the primary tick vectors. These vectors maintain an enzootic transmission but rarely feed on human 7. (Figure 1).
Figure 1.
Reported Cases, 2015
“Though Lyme disease cases have been reported in nearly every state, cases are reported from the infected person's county of residence, not the place where they were infected” 6.
The national incidence rate was 7.9 cases per 100,000 persons in 2015, and “96% of confirmed Lyme disease cases were reported in 14 states” 6:
Connecticut
Minnesota
Rhode Island
Deleware
New Hampshire
Vermont
Maine
New Jersey
Virginia
Maryland
New York
Wisconsin
Massachusetts
Pennsylvania
In a 2015 review article entitle “Lyme neuroborreliosis,” the authors reported the incidence of cases are 10 times higher than national surveillance per recent retrospective analyses from health insurance data. This data yielded annual rates of incidence for Lyme disease of 100-300 cases per 100, 000 persons in US and German 8. The review also states that the prevalence of Lyme Disease cases has increased substantially in the past two decades 8.
Nevertheless, there are many factors that contribute to this epidemiologic transmission dynamics of Borrelia burgodorerisensulato. These factors include conditions that favor tick survival, the density and infection rate of local vectors, the abundance and infectivity of reservoir hosts, and the likelihood and duration of human exposure to tick vectors 3.
Presentation
Tick Bite Without Symptoms
People who are exposed to endemic areas will sometimes notice a tick on their skin. It is important to properly remove the tick as promptly as possible. According to the CDC, it takes up to 36 to 48 hours to transmit the bacterium 6. It is recommended to remove the tick by using fine-tipped tweezers to grab the tick at the skin surface and steadily pull upward. If any mouth parts remain, remove them with tweezers. Thoroughly clean the area with rubbing alcohol, iodine scrub, or soap and water. Dispose of the tick by submerging it in alcohol or flushing it down the toilet 6.
Stage 1: Early Localized Infection
The person may also experience flu-like symptoms such as fever, chills, headache, stiff neck, fatigue, and body aches and pains within days to weeks 9. (Figure 2).
Figure 2.
After injecting into human skin, the spirochete may migrate outward producing an annular or spread hematogenously or through the lymphatics to other organs. An infection begins with the characteristic expanding erythema migrans (EM) as previously described by the Europeans in the early 1900’s. Erythema migrans initially develops as a small red spot macule or papule isolated to the site of the tick bite but enlarges within one to two weeks. During this incubation period EM center becomes erythematous and indurated and even vesicular 1. It can be one solid red oval or have the classic “bull’s eye” appearance. On the other hand, most patient may not remember a preceding tick bite due to the size of the nymphal Ixodes richness complex ticks 1.
Stage 2: Early Disseminated Infection
Infection with B. burgodorerisensumay not become symptomatic until its progression to Stage 2 and 3. Typically, stage 2 occurs within 3 to 10 weeks of inoculation and characterized as disseminated infections via hematogenous spread. Patients may develop multiple erythema migrans, with severe headaches and mild stiff neck, meningitis, cranial nerve VII palsy, carditis, AV block, migratory musculoskeletal pain and borrelia lymphocytoma. Borrelia Lymphocytoma is an uncommon presentation of early lyme disseminated infection that has only been reported in Europe. It is a bluish-red nodular lesion that appears most commonly on the ears in children and the nipple in adults but may also appear on the nose, extremities, and scrotum 1, 10, 11, 12
All signs and symptoms of stage 2 are intermittent and often changing. Some patients with untreated symptoms may become less severe and even have disappearance of symptoms within weeks of staging 1. Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine, reports about 15% of patient present with nonspecific systemic symptoms at stage 2 and another 15% may develop frank neurologic abnormalities such as meningitis, peripheral neuropathy cerebellar ataxia, sensory or motor radiculoneuropathy.
Stage 3: Late Disseminated Infection
After month to years of proceeding Ixodes complex tick infection, patients untreated are classified as stage 3. There is usually a period of latency 1, 10, 11, 12. Persistent arthritis is the hallmark of this stage. Patients may experience patterns of intermittent attacks of oligoarticular arthritis particularly in large joint like the knees. However, patients may also develop encephalitis or acrodermatitis chronica atrophicans (ACA) 8. ACA typically affects elderly woman who presents with solitary macular or annular erythemas often located in or near intertriginous areas such as the groin, axilla or popliteal fossa 13. Lymphadenopathy may also be present 1, 10, 11, 12.
Chronic Lyme Disease
In some Lyme disease patients, symptoms persist for years even after appropriate treatment. Chronic infection leads to persistent musculoskeletal, neurologic and cardiac symptoms that are the hallmark of chronic lyme disease. The nature of such chronic condition and its therapeutic management is of much debate.
Treatment
According to the IDSA’s 2006 guidelines the antibiotic, route of administration, and duration are all determined by the patient’s clinical manifestations and stage. Table 1 and Table 2 summarize the IDSA’s 2006 treatment guidelines for Lyme disease.
Table 1. Clinical presentation and therapy for the stages of Lyme Disease10.| Disease Stage | Clinical Manifestations | Treatment | Duration |
| Stage 1: Early localized | Erythema migrans | Oral Therapy | 14-21 days |
| Stage 2:Early disseminated | Multiple erythema migrans | Oral Therapy | 14-21 days |
| Isolated cranial nerve palsy | Oral Therapy | 14-21 days | |
| Meningoradiculoneuritis | Oral Therapy | 14-28 days | |
| Meningitis | Intravenous or oral | 14-21 days | |
| Carditis | |||
| -Ambulatory | Oral Therapy | 14-21 days | |
| -Hospitalized | Intravenous followed by oral | 14-21 days | |
| Borrelial lymphocytoma | Oral Therapy | 14-21 days | |
| Stage 3: Late | Arthritis | Oral Therapy | 28 days |
| Recurrent arthritis after oral therapy | Oral or intravenous | 28 days or 14-28 days | |
| Encephalitis | Intravenous Therapy | 14-28 days | |
| Acrodermatitis chronica atrophicans | Oral Therapy | 14-28 days |
| Treatment | Adult Dose | Pediatric Dose | |
| Oral Therapy | Doxycycline (patients > 8 yr) | 100 mg twice a day | 4 mg/kg (up to 100 mg) twice a day |
| Amoxicillin | 500 mg three times a day | 50 mg/kg (up to 500 mg) three times a day | |
| Cefuroxime axetil | 500 mg twice a day | 30 mg/kg (up to 500 mg) twice a day | |
| Intravenous Therapy | Ceftriaxone | 2 g once a day | 50-75 mg/kg (up to 2 g) once a day |
| Cefotaxime | 2 g every 8 h | 150-200 mg/kg (up to 2 g)every 8 h | |
| Penicillin G | 18-24 million U/d divided every 4 h | 200,000-400,000 mg/kg (up to 2 g)every 8 h |
The Controversy
The CDC defines the persistent symptoms of fatigue, pain, or joint and muscle aches, lasting greater than 6 months in Lyme disease patient after proper treatment, as “Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome” (PTLDS) 6. On the other hand, the IDSA refers to this consolation of symptoms as Post-Lyme Syndrome and argues that there is no concrete evidence that spirochetes persist in these patients. The IDSA propose that the chronic symptoms are due to an autoimmune response. Therefore they disagree with the use of long-term antibiotics for persistent symptoms of Lyme disease. In contrast, the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) insist that the chronic symptoms are due to the persistence of spirochetes and define these symptoms as “chronic Lyme disease” (CLD). The ILADS conclude that the bacteria are undetected by traditional assay test. They contend that long term antibiotics should be used to combat Chronic Lyme Disease.
In 2006, the IDSA developed and released treatment guidelines, which advised against long- term antibiotic treatment. However the resultant guidelines failed to address persistent spirochetal infection in chronic Lyme disease patients, who often remain symptomatic after short-term antibiotic therapy 14. These guidelines influenced medical practitioners’ treatment decisions and had been used by insurance companies as justification to deny coverage 15.
This severely diminishes the ability to obtain long-term antibiotic treatment for those patients who have persistent symptoms and who cannot afford to pay out-of-pocket.
In 2008, Richard Blumenthal, the Connecticut Attorney General initiated an investigation into the development of the 2006 IDSA disease treatment guidelines 16. He accused the IDSA panel of undisclosed conflicts of interest of panel members and its chairman and disregarding the existence of chronic Lyme disease 15.
The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) and the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) provided “independent corroboration” that the 2006 guidelines were developed from evidence-based medicine 16. However, it was later revealed that 11 members of the IDSA guidelines panel were authors of the NEJM article. The AAN had similar overlapping authorship 17. Both the NEJM and the AAN failed to disclose this obvious conflict of interest.
The investigation was terminated and the IDSA did agree to an independent review of the 2006 guidelines 15. The independent review by an expert panel was published in 2010. The panel unanimously supported the 2006 guidelines, stating, “No changes or revisions to the 2006 Lyme guidelines are necessary at this time”. They also purported that long-term antibiotics are “unproven and potentially dangerous” 17.
The 2006 IDSA’s Lyme Disease treatment guidelines remain unchanged and appear validated. However, several states have enacted laws that allow licensed physicians to prescribe long-term antibiotics for therapeutic reasons for patients clinically diagnosed with Lyme disease. Additionally, Connecticut and Rhode Island have passed laws mandating insurance coverage when long-term antibiotic therapy is deemed medically necessary.
Furthermore, there is still a difference in recommended treatment for certain manifestations of Lyme Disease (Table 3).
Table 3. Comparison of Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) recommendations for Lyme disease treatment10,11,12.| Treatment Focus | IDSA | ILADS |
| Treatment of a tick bite without symptoms of Lyme disease | Doxycycline 200 mg single dose | Doxycycline, 100 mg bid for 20 days |
| Erythema migrans | Doxycycline, amoxicillin, or cefuroxime for 14-21 days | Doxycycline, amoxicillin, or cefuroxime for 28-42 days or azithromycin for at least 21 days |
| “Persisting symptoms of Lyme disease” | No antibiotic therapy | Multiple agents (individually or in combination) are mentioned without specific doses or duration recommended |
Diagnosis
When the hallmark, bull’s eye rash or erythema migrans is present during the early stage, the diagnosis is clinically based on history and physical exam and no blood test is required. When there is no erythema migrans rash, the diagnosis is still made clinically and a blood test can help confirm the diagnosis.
The CDC recommends a two-step process when testing blood 6. These blood tests are most reliable about 2 weeks post-innoculation, as the body has had time to make antibodies. The following diagram shows the steps as laid out by the CDC 6: (Figure 3).
Figure 3.
The first test, an enzyme immunoassay, has high sensitivity, meaning however, there could be false positives and therefore must be confirmed by the second test. The second test, an immunoblot test, commonly called a “Western Blot” which has high specificity yet, this means there could be some false negatives. Theoretically when a highly sensitivity test is followed by a highly specific test, only a few true positives are excluded and rarely any false positives are included6. Nevertheless for specific laboratory case ascertainment, a positive B. burgodorferi culture plus a positive result from the two-tier testing is sufficient in the diagnosis of Lyme Disease for patient with symptoms onset less than 30 days 18.
Differential Diagnosis
Lyme disease is known as the “Great Imitator” because it has very nonspecific symptoms that can look like many other conditions. Patients of Lyme disease are frequently misdiagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, multiple sclerosis, and various psychiatric illnesses, including depression. Misdiagnosis with these other diseases may delay the correct diagnosis and treatment as the underlying infection progresses unchecked 18.
As previously stated systemic symptoms of Lyme Disease can be nonspecific and look very much like the flu. Consequently this can make diagnosing Lyme disease very difficult in some patients. One major difference in the constellation symptoms characteristic to the flu, is that in early Lyme disease these symptoms are intermittent with a longer duration in comparison to the flu 1, 2.
Finally, it is important to always consider other conditions as well as possible co- infections when Lyme disease is suspected. There are at least four known pathogens in addition to Lyme disease that is transmitted by the black-legged or the Ixodes ticks. The most common co-infections that occur with Lyme disease are Anaplasma
Phagocytophilum, which causes Human Granulocytic Anaplasmosis, previously known as Human Granulocytic Ehrlichiosis; and Babesia Microti, the primary cause of Babesiosis. These co-infections are an emerging problem and may exacerbate clinical features of Lyme disease 19.
Prognosis
When treated early, Lyme disease is easily and rapidly cleared, preventing later stages of disease. However, these later stages of Lyme disease also respond well to treatment if therapy is commenced soon after the appearance of symptoms 1, 2.
Although there continues to be percentage of patients infected with Borrelia burgodoreri who develop chronic Lyme Disease, most patients recover fully from this infection 1, 2. It is critical to identify chronic lyme disease patient as their conditions may be intermittent but debilitating.
Conclusion
No matter what side of the fence you stand, Post-Lyme Treatment Syndrome or Chronic Lyme Disease, one thing is abundantly clear, more research still needs to be done!
Though the course has been long and rocky, science and medicine have already taken a step in the right direction when it comes to diagnosing and treating patients with Lyme Disease. Over the next ten years, there should be advancements both academically and pharmacologically that will hopefully take Lyme disease out of the lime light and give much needed relief to those with Chronic Lyme Disease.
References
- 1.G P Wormser. (2006) The clinical assessment, treatment, and prevention of Lyme disease, human granulocytic anaplasmosis, and babesiosis: clinical practice guidelines by the Infectious Diseases Society of America.Clinical Infectious Diseases. 43(9), 1089-1134.
- 2.R Johnson Stricker, L. (2008) . Chronic Lyme Disease and the “Axis of Evil”.Future Microbiology; London 3(6), 621-4.
- 5.S MD Allen, H MD John, R MD Shaun, M BS Jon, M. (1979) . Correlation of Serum IgM and Cryoglobulin with Activity and IgG with Remission.American College of Rheumatology 22(5), 471-483.
- 6.Schwartz A M, Hinckley A F, Mead P S, Hook S A, Kugeler K J. (2015) . Surveillance for Lyme Disease — United States,MMWR Surveillance Summary Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 66(No. SS-22): 1-12.
- 7.Jr J H Oliver, Lin T, Gao L, K L Clark, C W Banks et al. (2003) An enzootic transmission cycle of Lyme borreliosis spirochetes in the southeastern United States.PNAS. 100(20), 11642-11645.
- 8.Koedel U, Fingerle V, H W Pfister. (2015) Lyme neuroborreliosis— epidemiology, diagnosis and management.NatureReviewsNeurology. 11(8), 446.
- 9.Stupica D, Lusa L, Ruzić-Sabljić E, Cerar T, Strle F. (2012) Treatment of erythema migrans with doxycycline for 10 days versus 15 days.Clin Infect Dis;55(3):. 343-350.
- 11.Kowalski T J, Tata S, Berth W, Mathiason M A, Agger W A.Antibiotic treatment duration and long-term outcomes of patients with early Lyme disease from a Lyme disease- hyperendemic area.Clin InfectDis.50(4):. 512-520.
- 12.Sanchez E, Vannier E, Wormser G P, Hu L T. (2016) Diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of Lyme disease, human granulocytic anaplasmosis, and babesiosis: A review. , JAMA 315(16), 1767-77.
- 13.Müller R R, Means T K, Shin J J. (2007) . Chemokine Signatures in the Skin Disorders of Lyme Borreliosis in Europe: predominance of CXCL9 and CXCLIO in Erythema Migrans and Acrodermatitis and CXCL13 in Lymphocytoma.Infect Immun;75: 4621-8.
- 14.Middelveen M J, Sapi E, Burke J. (2018) Persistent Borrelia Infection. in Patients with Ongoing Symptoms of Lyme Disease.Healthcare 6(2), 33.
- 15.Johnson L, Stricker R. (2009) . Attorney General Forces Infectious Diseases Society of America to Redo Lyme Guidelines Due to Flawed Development Process.Journal of Medical Ethics,35(5) 283-288.
- 17.Disease Lyme.Guidelines Revised: Defusing a Ticking Time Bomb?- The American Lyme Disease Foundation Reports on New Recommendations.Journal of Musculoskeletal Medicine;. , Darien. April,2007 4(24), 146.